When the player shuts the closet, the Plushbabies will start twitching and making distorted noises. In Circus Baby level, the Plushbabies sit in the closet with the player. Should the player fail to find one before it reaches them, the Plushbaby will end their run with a jumpscare. If the player leaves their light on too long, it will go out, and they will have to wait for it to recharge. Before they attack the player, they will say something to the player to warn them that they are running out of time. In the Plushbaby level, the player must find them in the dark room and shine their flashlight at them to make them disappear.

Plushbabies appear in two mini-games: the Plushbaby level in Dark Rooms and the Circus Baby level in Night Terrors. They both share the same general behaviors as the red Plushbaby. The Plushbaby in the yellow outfit, referred to as 'Blind' in the files, has her right eye blacked out, with only the stitching of her eye being visible. The Plushbaby in the blue outfit, referred to as 'Stitch' in the files, has a faint red stitch running from her side to the middle of her chest. While the Plushbaby in the red outfit has no distinguishing characteristics, the other two have aspects unique to them. One has a red outfit, one blue, and one yellow. They have a red nose with a smile on their mouth with red cheeks connected to it. The orange triangle has a small fan printed on it. They have a red skirt and two small legs with red and a yellow circle at the tip of them, representing shoes.

They have a red top on their stomach with an orange triangle on their belly. They are white skinned clown-like plushies with light blue eyes and orange hair in pigtails. The Plushbabies' appearances seem to be based on the Circus Baby Funko plushie.

Freddy fazbear pizzeria simulator wiki